Why Biden’s nominee to manage banks is proving so controversial : NPR

Cornell College Professor Saule Omarova testifying on fintech at a listening to organized by the Senate Banking committee on Sept. 18, 2018. At present, Omarova is President Biden’s nominee to go the company that oversees nearly all of the belongings held by the nation’s banks, and she is going to seem in entrance of the identical Senate committee for her affirmation listening to on Thursday.

Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and City Affairs


cover caption

toggle caption

Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and City Affairs


Cornell College Professor Saule Omarova testifying on fintech at a listening to organized by the Senate Banking committee on Sept. 18, 2018. At present, Omarova is President Biden’s nominee to go the company that oversees nearly all of the belongings held by the nation’s banks, and she is going to seem in entrance of the identical Senate committee for her affirmation listening to on Thursday.

Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and City Affairs

The president’s decide to turn into a prime banking regulator does not often entice quite a lot of curiosity, however this time is totally different.

President Biden has nominated Saule Omarova, a legislation professor at Cornell College, to be the following head of the Workplace of the Comptroller of the Forex (OCC), which is accountable for regulating the belongings held by greater than 1,000 banks.

At Omarova’s affirmation listening to on Thursday, many Democrats on the Senate Banking Committee lined up in assist of her nomination.

Progressives have applauded her nomination, seeing in Omarova an individual who would convey a harder method to banks at an company that has been criticized for being too pleasant with the sector. However there was no indication any Republican on the committee will again her. Omarova’s critics say she is a “radical” nominee who desires to nationalize banking.

Omarova has attracted unusually private criticism. On the listening to, Sen. John Kennedy (R-La.) introduced up her childhood within the former Soviet Union, and Republicans cited a tutorial paper she just lately wrote proposing a reinvention of the U.S. monetary system, which The Wall Avenue Journal’s conservative editorial board argues is proof she hasn’t “repudiated her Soviet-era views.”

Omarova, who got here to the U.S. as a college pupil, and is now a U.S. citizen, strongly denies she holds communist views. She accused her critics of singling her out as a result of she is a girl and a minority.

This is a have a look at Omarova and her nomination.

What’s the OCC?

The Workplace of the Comptroller of the Forex, which has been round since 1863, regulates and supervises banks, from smaller, group lenders to giant establishments, together with Financial institution of America, Citibank, and Wells Fargo.

Though the OCC is housed throughout the Treasury Division, it operates independently, and a part of its mandate is “guaranteeing truthful entry and equal therapy to financial institution clients.”

The Treasury Constructing is seen in Washington, D.C. on Could 4. The OCC is somewhat recognized regulatory physique inside Treasury with an outsized position overseeing banking belongings.

Patrick Semansky/AP


cover caption

toggle caption

Patrick Semansky/AP


The Treasury Constructing is seen in Washington, D.C. on Could 4. The OCC is somewhat recognized regulatory physique inside Treasury with an outsized position overseeing banking belongings.

Patrick Semansky/AP

Why is that this job so essential?

Regardless of its comparatively small measurement, the OCC has a large regulatory footprint.

Altogether, the establishments the OCC oversees have belongings price nearly $15 trillion. They characterize 65% of all “U.S. business banking belongings,” in accordance with the OCC.

The OCC has beforehand come below criticism over perceptions it is too near the banks it regulates. The comptroller through the Trump administration, Joseph Otting, reportedly referred to banks as his “clients.”

Who’s Saule Omarova?

The White Home’s nominee to be the following comptroller of the forex is at present a professor of company legislation and monetary regulation at Cornell College.

Beforehand, Omarova labored as a lawyer at Davis Polk, and through the George W. Bush administration, she was a particular advisor for regulatory coverage within the Treasury Division.

Though her analysis is wide-ranging, on all the things from vitality coverage to infrastructure funding, Omarova is a well-known scholar of monetary regulation.

A head portrait of Saule Omarova, a professor of company legislation and monetary regulation professor at Cornell College. Omarova has confronted withering criticism from some Republicans and conservatives over her views on revamping the monetary system.

Cornell College


cover caption

toggle caption

Cornell College


A head portrait of Saule Omarova, a professor of company legislation and monetary regulation professor at Cornell College. Omarova has confronted withering criticism from some Republicans and conservatives over her views on revamping the monetary system.

Cornell College

“Saule is extensively thought to be one of many prime monetary regulatory students on the planet,” says Jeremy Kress, an assistant professor of enterprise legislation on the College of Michigan. “Whether or not you agree together with her, or disagree together with her, you’ll be able to’t have an entire debate about present matters in U.S. banking legislation and U.S. monetary regulation with out considering what Saule has written on the subject.”

However her analysis has come below withering assault by some critics.

In a single paper, Omarova suggests the federal authorities may supply a checking account to each American via the Federal Reserve. Supporters of that proposal say it could cut back the variety of “unbanked” individuals considerably. Critics argue it could undermine business banks.

In one other article, she requires the creation of an company not in contrast to the Meals and Drug Administration, that will be charged with approving or rejecting new monetary merchandise.

What do Saule Omarova’s critics say?

In a fiery speech in October, Sen. Toomey advised his colleagues, “I do not suppose I’ve ever seen a extra radical alternative for any regulatory spot in our federal authorities.”

Omarova “clearly has an aversion to something like free-market capitalism,” the senator mentioned, citing examples of her tutorial work.

Throughout his speech, Toomey mentioned Omarova’s curiosity in these matters and others may have been formed by her upbringing.

“You could possibly ask your self, ‘The place would an individual even provide you with these concepts?'” he mentioned. “Nicely, perhaps a contributing issue might be in if an individual grew up within the former Soviet Union, and went to Moscow State College, and attended there on a Vladimir Lenin Tutorial Scholarship.”

Omarova was born in what’s now Kazakhstan. She got here to the U.S. as a part of an alternate program when she was a pupil at Moscow State College in 1991. However when the Soviet Union dissolved, she was stranded within the U.S. At present, she is a U.S. citizen.

Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., is pictured throughout a a Senate Banking Committee listening to on Sept. 14. Toomey, the rating member of the committee, has been probably the most outspoken Senate critics of Omarova.

Evelyn Hockstein/POOL/AFP by way of Getty Photos


cover caption

toggle caption

Evelyn Hockstein/POOL/AFP by way of Getty Photos


Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., is pictured throughout a a Senate Banking Committee listening to on Sept. 14. Toomey, the rating member of the committee, has been probably the most outspoken Senate critics of Omarova.

Evelyn Hockstein/POOL/AFP by way of Getty Photos

What have Omarova and her supporters mentioned?

Omarova has defended her analysis and pushed again towards the non-public nature of the assaults towards her.

“I’m not a communist,” she shot again to Kennedy throughout Thursday’s listening to after the Louisiana senator mentioned he didn’t know whether or not to explain her as a “professor” or a “comrade.”

“I don’t subscribe to that ideology. I couldn’t select the place I used to be born,” she additionally mentioned.

In an interview with MSNBC, Omarova mentioned, “My complete tutorial profession has been centered round this subject of how to make sure that our monetary system is steady, efficient, and environment friendly.”

Her supporters have additionally denounced Omarova’s critics. In an interview with NPR, the chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, Sen. Sherrod Brown, D-Ohio, known as Toomey’s remarks “despicable” and “character assassination— a time period he used once more Thursday, after Kennedy questioned Omarova.

How would Omarova method the OCC job if confirmed?

Monetary consultants say Omarova is prone to undertake a harder method to banks, however many agree that her earlier analysis has been misrepresented.

Progressives would welcome a harder method to banks, and Omarova’s candidacy is according to the Biden’s administration method to regulation to this point.

“I do suppose that a part of what she represents is an effort to shake up the established order,” says Kathryn Choose, a professor at Columbia Regulation Faculty. “The comptroller has usually been seen as overly conscious of the pursuits of the trade that it oversees.”

In line with Choose, Omarova would see that relationship in a different way.

“She is actually decided to ensure that banks are offering core providers to the individuals who want them,” she says.

On the similar time, consultants declare Omarova’s critics, together with Toomey, are misrepresenting her analysis.

“Many people do thought experiments about how we might reimagine or restructure the monetary system if we have been ranging from scratch,” says Kress from the College of Michigan.

“That is to not say that any of us who’ve undergone these thought workouts, if put ready of energy within the authorities, would search to impact this form of large-scale modifications.”

What is the probability that Omarova is confirmed?

Regardless of pushback from Republicans, the White Home pressed forward with Omarova’s nomination.

“Saule Omarova is eminently certified and was nominated for this position given her robust observe file on regulation and powerful tutorial credentials,” an administration official mentioned in an announcement to NPR. “The White Home strongly helps this historic nomination.”

However Democrats have a skinny majority within the Senate total, and on the Senate Banking Committee, the place they cannot afford to lose a single vote.

In the course of the listening to, Sen. Jon Tester, D-Mont., one of many extra reasonable members of the committee, expressed some considerations about Omarova.

“A few of Dr. Omarova’s previous statements concerning the position of presidency within the monetary system elevate actual considerations about her potential to impartially serve on the Workplace of the Comptroller of the Forex, and I am wanting ahead to discussing them together with her at her listening to,” Tester mentioned in an announcement earlier than the listening to.

However Sen. Brown is optimistic Omarova’s nomination will get huge, bipartisan assist.

“I care vastly about this nomination,” he mentioned. “We will make it occur.”

https://www.npr.org/2021/11/18/1056252505/saule-omarova-occ-treasury-nomination-confirmation-hearing-criticism