EU Criticized For Sluggish Response To Hungary’s Crackdown On Press Freedom : NPR

The European Union condemned the closure of an impartial radio station in Hungary, however critics say the EU has been gradual to punish Budapest for repeatedly violating democratic rules.


One in every of Hungary’s final remaining impartial radio stations was taken off the radio. It is the most recent blow to press freedom in Hungary. The European Union has condemned this motion. However critics say the EU has been gradual to punish Hungary for repeatedly violating democratic rules. Here is NPR’s Rob Schmitz.


UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #1: (Non-English language spoken).

ROB SCHMITZ, BYLINE: On February 14, Budapest’s Klubradio broadcast its information program to three 1/2 million folks, greater than a 3rd of the inhabitants of Hungary, prefer it has for greater than twenty years. The following day, it was pulled off the air.

MIHALY HARDY: Now we have misplaced about 60 to 70% of our standard viewers.

SCHMITZ: Klubradio head of reports Mihaly Hardy says his most devoted listeners nonetheless tune in via the net.


UNIDENTIFIED PERSON #2: (Non-English language spoken).

SCHMITZ: They’re accustomed to their beloved station’s precarious political scenario. Eleven years in the past, Klubradio misplaced 90% of its income shortly after Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban got here to energy and ordered all state-backed firms to cease promoting over impartial media. Its listeners stepped up with a pledge drive that to at the present time funds 90% of the station’s working prices. Hardy explains why.

HARDY: About 80% of the media protection in Hungary is supplied by both government-owned or government-run or pro-government media. That features 470 newspapers, TV stations, radios, web sites, et cetera. We’re the final main surviving impartial radio station.

SCHMITZ: A spokesman for Viktor Orban emailed NPR a press release that learn, the latest resolution concerning Klubradio is of authorized nature by the impartial judiciary. In Hungary, the precept of separation of powers prevails. Hardy says this could not be farther from the reality. He says Orban’s crackdown on the free press has been happening for 10 years, and the European Union’s response has been gradual and weak.

HARDY: The EU simply despatched in committees. They investigated. Then they filed experiences. Then they made some speeches on the European Parliament. However nothing actually occurred.

SCHMITZ: The EU’s tepid response to Viktor Orban’s chipping away of democratic establishments in Hungary is complacency on the highest degree, says Judy Dempsey from the assume tank Carnegie Europe.

JUDY DEMPSEY: And it’s extraordinary as a result of the entire structure of the European Union was constructed on the basic problem of values, freedom of the press, division of powers, accountability, impartial judiciary, checks and balances. And Orban has really made a mockery of those values.

SCHMITZ: Dempsey and Hardy say German Chancellor Angela Merkel, if she needed to, would have sufficient political and financial leverage to guide an EU-wide opposition to Orban. For years, Orban’s Fidesz occasion was allowed to stay in the identical political bloc within the European Parliament as Merkel’s center-right occasion, serving to to take care of the dominance of that bloc. On prime of that, many huge German firms do enterprise in Hungary. However they are saying that may be the explanation why Germany hasn’t accomplished a lot about Orban’s tightening grip on energy in Hungary.

ELMAR BROK: Excuse me after I say this argument is absolutely silly and may come solely from assume tankers. They’re extra tank than assume.

SCHMITZ: Elmar Brok sits on the board of Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union Celebration and is the previous chairman of the European Parliament Committee on International Affairs. He says a lot of Orban’s political technique is to defend Hungary from what he deems as exterior enemies.

BROK: Do you assume Orban would simply give in as a result of Germany is so huge? I do know Viktor Orban since 1988. I used to be the primary one that introduced him to Brussels.

SCHMITZ: Again then, Orban was a younger, liberal chief who advocated for democracy. Over time, Brok says his good friend modified. And he step by step used resentment in his personal nation in the direction of the EU and weaponized it to stay in energy.

BROK: It is a technique to be unpopular in Europe and to be blamed as a way to win the elections.

SCHMITZ: Brok is not buddies with Orban. A few years in the past, he stood up throughout a European Parliament assembly whereas Orban was within the room to declare that he was ending his private relationship with the Hungarian chief. Brok says it has been emotionally troublesome for him to see a person who he as soon as thought of good friend go to this point to betray the democratic rules of Europe. And he says there’s a restrict to what the EU can do to cease Orban.

BROK: Once we name on such international locations to go together with the rule of regulation, then we are able to solely use, on a European degree, what our authorized devices give to us.

SCHMITZ: For instance, there’s a option to droop the rights of an EU member state that violates the bloc’s core values, it is Article 7 of the treaty of the EU. However it requires a unanimous vote. And Brok says Poland, one other member state whose ruling occasion is chipping away at its democratic establishments, would veto such a transfer. Brok says he is labored to attempt to dispose of the Article 7 veto rule to no avail. Katalin Cseh, a member of the European Parliament and the primary opposition occasion in Hungary, says the EU’s lack of ability to behave in opposition to Hungary and Poland signifies that extra international locations are actually vulnerable to anti-democratic political actions.

KATALIN CSEH: We fairly often speak about Hungary and Poland. However there are very worrying indicators elsewhere in Slovenia, in Bulgaria. And if the EU doesn’t take motion to place an finish to this, it might turn into a really contagious impact. And all the stability of the union may very well be undermined.

SCHMITZ: Cseh says there may be hope. On the finish of final yr, the EU adopted a rule-of-law-conditionality mechanism. It means if the rule of regulation in any EU member state is being violated, then the bloc can cease the circulation of EU cash to that specific member state. Its use in opposition to Hungary may price it billions in EU funding because the nation prepares for elections subsequent yr. And simply yesterday, Orban’s Fidesz occasion was compelled to withdraw from that center-right bloc that dominates within the European Parliament. Cseh says this all comes a decade too late. However it’s higher late than by no means.

Rob Schmitz, NPR Information, Berlin.


Copyright © 2021 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at for additional info.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR contractor, and produced utilizing a proprietary transcription course of developed with NPR. This textual content might not be in its closing type and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could differ. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.